‘Perfect Match’ Season 4’s Cast Is a Reality TV Fever Dream
Very ready for this Bri Balram and DeMari Davis reunion.
Time to celebrate, friends! Netflix just announced that its most chaotic reality dating show, Perfect Match, will be back for its fourth season on May 13, and the cast is…something! Among the singles (which include reality stars from both within and outside of the Netflix dating show universe, including Love Island, Vanderpump Rules, and Married at First Sight) there are tons of familiar faces, like Love Island USA’s Kassy Castillo, Love Is Blind’s Jimmy Presnell, and (checks notes) Ohio State basketball team member/content creator Jimmy Sotos…?
Chances are, things are going to get messy, especially since the experience will bring some former flames back together. (I’m looking at you, Bri Balram and DeMari Davis.) And since this was filmed back in fall 2025, I already have some insight into who may have found a lasting connection in Tulum (remember that random date between Ally Lewber from VPR and Dave Hand from MAFS back in November?) and who definitely didn’t (such as the two cast members listed below who are currently in relationships with people they did not meet on Perfect Match).
Keep scrolling to meet all the Perfect Match season 4 contestants (as well as all of their reality TV exes).
Name: Alison Ogden
How you know her: Building the Band season 1
Notable ex: Conor Smith from Building the Band
Name: Ally Lewber
How you know her: Vanderpump Rules seasons 10 and 11
Notable ex: James Kennedy from Vanderpump Rules
Name: Bri Balram
How you know her: Too Hot to Handle season 6, Battle Camp season 1
Notable exes: DeMari Davis from Too Hot to Handle, Louis Russell from Battle Camp
Currently dating: Lochan Nowacki from Love Island
Name: Chris Dahlan
How you know him: Age of Attraction season 1
Notable ex: Leah Woolfolk from Age of Attraction
Name: Danny Spongberg
How you know him: Temptation Island season 1
Notable ex: Ashley Moore from Temptation Island
Name: Dave Hand
How you know him: Married at First Sight Australia season 12
Notable ex: Jamie Marinos from Married at First Sight Australia
Name: DeMari Davis
How you know him: Too Hot to Handle season 6
Notable ex: Bri Balram from Too Hot to Handle
Name: Hashim Moore
How you know him: Temptation Island season 1
Notable ex: Not yet!
Name: Jimmy Presnell
How you know him: Love Is Blind season 6
Notable ex: Chelsea Blackwell from Love Is Blind
Name: Jimmy Sotos
How you know him: Ohio State basketball team, TikTok
Notable ex: Not yet!
Name: Kassy Castillo
How you know her: Love Island USA seasons 5 and 6
Notable exes: Leo Dionicio from Love Island USA, Rob Rausch from Love Island USA
Name: Katherine LaPrell
How you know her: Too Hot to Handle season 6
Notable ex: Charlie Jeer from Too Hot to Handle
Name: Kayla Richart
How you know her: Too Hot to Handle season 4
Notable exes: Seb Melrose from Too Hot to Handle, Isaac Francis from Too Hot to Handle
Name: Mackenzie Bellows
How you know her: Squid Game: The Challenge season 2
Notable ex: Not yet!
Name: Marissa George
How you know her: Love Is Blind season 7
Notable ex: Ramses Prashad from Love Is Blind
Name: Natalie Cruz
How you know her: Temptation Island season 1
Notable ex: Grant Larsen from Temptation Island
Name: Nick Pellecchia
How you know him: Million Dollar Secret season 2
Notable ex: Not yet!
Name: Sophie Willett
How you know her: Love Is Blind UK season 2
Notable ex: Demola Ayilara from Love Is Blind UK
Name: Weston Richey
How you know him: Love Island USA season 1
Notable ex: Emily Salch from Love Island USA
Name: Yamen Sanders
How you know him: Love Island USA season 1, Temptation Island season 1, Love Island: All Stars season 3
Notable exes: Aïssata Diallo from Love Island USA, Tayler Byrd from Temptation Island
Currently dating: Whitney Adebayo from Love Island: All Stars
Readers Also Read
Some '90s Kids Movies You Should Rewatch RTFN
There Are So Many Good Movies on Netflix Rn
Are Sydney and Xzavier Together Post-’Island’?
The Boys Season 5 Schedule
